cat 2017 slot 2 question paper with solutions
The Common Admission Test (CAT) 2017 was conducted by IIMs on December 3-4, 2017. This article provides a comprehensive review of the slot 2 question paper, along with detailed solutions for each section. Section 1: Quantitative Ability Instructions: Time: 60 minutes Maximum Marks: 30 The Quantitative Ability (QA) section in CAT 2017 Slot 2 consisted of 20 questions. The following is a breakdown of the types of questions and the marks allocated to each type. Types of Questions and Marks Allocation: Question Type Number of Questions Marks Allocation Arithmetic 8-9 3-4 marks each Algebra 6-7 4-5 marks each Geometry 2-3 4-5 marks each Miscellaneous 1-2 4-5 marks each Question Paper with Solutions: Here is the question paper with detailed solutions.
- Lucky Ace Palacenew
Luck&Luxury100% / $1500Casino popularity:Collecting more data...Payment methods- Wagering: 35 x (b)
- Withdrawal time: 1 days
- Minimum deposit to casino: $30
- Bonus max bet: $5
- Established: 2024
- Free Spins: 200
- 1st Deposit Bonus:100% / $1500 + 200 Free Spins
- Bonus code: FRUIT22nd Deposit Bonus:100% / $1500 + 75 Free Spins
- Bonus code: FRUIT33rd Deposit Bonus:75% / $3000 + 75 Free Spins
- Bonus code: FRUIT44th Deposit Bonus:50% / $4500 + 200 Free Spins
- Leading selection of slots
- VISA casino site
- HD streaming casino games
- Newly unveiled casino
- Signup offer now available
- Mr. Gamble special bonuses
Show more -
- Starlight Betting Lounge
Celestial Bet100% / $1500Casino popularity:Collecting more data...Payment methods- Wagering: 35 x (b)
- Withdrawal time: 1 days
- Minimum deposit to casino: $30
- Bonus max bet: $5
- Established: 2024
- Free Spins: 200
- 1st Deposit Bonus:100% / $1500 + 200 Free Spins
- Bonus code: FRUIT22nd Deposit Bonus:100% / $1500 + 75 Free Spins
- Bonus code: FRUIT33rd Deposit Bonus:75% / $3000 + 75 Free Spins
- Bonus code: FRUIT44th Deposit Bonus:50% / $4500 + 200 Free Spins
- Leading selection of slots
- VISA casino site
- HD streaming casino games
- Newly unveiled casino
- Signup offer now available
- Mr. Gamble special bonuses
Show more -
- Cash King Palace
Royal Wins100% / $1500Casino popularity:Collecting more data...Payment methods- Wagering: 35 x (b)
- Withdrawal time: 1 days
- Minimum deposit to casino: $30
- Bonus max bet: $5
- Established: 2024
- Free Spins: 200
- 1st Deposit Bonus:100% / $1500 + 200 Free Spins
- Bonus code: FRUIT22nd Deposit Bonus:100% / $1500 + 75 Free Spins
- Bonus code: FRUIT33rd Deposit Bonus:75% / $3000 + 75 Free Spins
- Bonus code: FRUIT44th Deposit Bonus:50% / $4500 + 200 Free Spins
- Leading selection of slots
- VISA casino site
- HD streaming casino games
- Newly unveiled casino
- Signup offer now available
- Mr. Gamble special bonuses
Show more -
- Spin Palace Casino
Win Big Now100% / $1500Casino popularity:Collecting more data...Payment methods- Wagering: 35 x (b)
- Withdrawal time: 1 days
- Minimum deposit to casino: $30
- Bonus max bet: $5
- Established: 2024
- Free Spins: 200
- 1st Deposit Bonus:100% / $1500 + 200 Free Spins
- Bonus code: FRUIT22nd Deposit Bonus:100% / $1500 + 75 Free Spins
- Bonus code: FRUIT33rd Deposit Bonus:75% / $3000 + 75 Free Spins
- Bonus code: FRUIT44th Deposit Bonus:50% / $4500 + 200 Free Spins
- Leading selection of slots
- VISA casino site
- HD streaming casino games
- Newly unveiled casino
- Signup offer now available
- Mr. Gamble special bonuses
Show more -
- Silver Fox Slots
Elegance+Fun100% / $1500Casino popularity:Collecting more data...Payment methods- Wagering: 35 x (b)
- Withdrawal time: 1 days
- Minimum deposit to casino: $30
- Bonus max bet: $5
- Established: 2024
- Free Spins: 200
- 1st Deposit Bonus:100% / $1500 + 200 Free Spins
- Bonus code: FRUIT22nd Deposit Bonus:100% / $1500 + 75 Free Spins
- Bonus code: FRUIT33rd Deposit Bonus:75% / $3000 + 75 Free Spins
- Bonus code: FRUIT44th Deposit Bonus:50% / $4500 + 200 Free Spins
- Leading selection of slots
- VISA casino site
- HD streaming casino games
- Newly unveiled casino
- Signup offer now available
- Mr. Gamble special bonuses
Show more -
- Golden Spin Casino
Luxury Play100% / $1500Casino popularity:Collecting more data...Payment methods- Wagering: 35 x (b)
- Withdrawal time: 1 days
- Minimum deposit to casino: $30
- Bonus max bet: $5
- Established: 2024
- Free Spins: 200
- 1st Deposit Bonus:100% / $1500 + 200 Free Spins
- Bonus code: FRUIT22nd Deposit Bonus:100% / $1500 + 75 Free Spins
- Bonus code: FRUIT33rd Deposit Bonus:75% / $3000 + 75 Free Spins
- Bonus code: FRUIT44th Deposit Bonus:50% / $4500 + 200 Free Spins
- Leading selection of slots
- VISA casino site
- HD streaming casino games
- Newly unveiled casino
- Signup offer now available
- Mr. Gamble special bonuses
Show more -
- Royal Fortune Gaming
Opulence & Thrills100% / $1500Casino popularity:Collecting more data...Payment methods- Wagering: 35 x (b)
- Withdrawal time: 1 days
- Minimum deposit to casino: $30
- Bonus max bet: $5
- Established: 2024
- Free Spins: 200
- 1st Deposit Bonus:100% / $1500 + 200 Free Spins
- Bonus code: FRUIT22nd Deposit Bonus:100% / $1500 + 75 Free Spins
- Bonus code: FRUIT33rd Deposit Bonus:75% / $3000 + 75 Free Spins
- Bonus code: FRUIT44th Deposit Bonus:50% / $4500 + 200 Free Spins
- Leading selection of slots
- VISA casino site
- HD streaming casino games
- Newly unveiled casino
- Signup offer now available
- Mr. Gamble special bonuses
Show more -
- Lucky Ace Casino
Luck&Luxury100% / $1500Casino popularity:Collecting more data...Payment methods- Wagering: 35 x (b)
- Withdrawal time: 1 days
- Minimum deposit to casino: $30
- Bonus max bet: $5
- Established: 2024
- Free Spins: 200
- 1st Deposit Bonus:100% / $1500 + 200 Free Spins
- Bonus code: FRUIT22nd Deposit Bonus:100% / $1500 + 75 Free Spins
- Bonus code: FRUIT33rd Deposit Bonus:75% / $3000 + 75 Free Spins
- Bonus code: FRUIT44th Deposit Bonus:50% / $4500 + 200 Free Spins
- Leading selection of slots
- VISA casino site
- HD streaming casino games
- Newly unveiled casino
- Signup offer now available
- Mr. Gamble special bonuses
Show more -
- Diamond Crown Casino
Opulence & Fun100% / $1500Casino popularity:Collecting more data...Payment methods- Wagering: 35 x (b)
- Withdrawal time: 1 days
- Minimum deposit to casino: $30
- Bonus max bet: $5
- Established: 2024
- Free Spins: 200
- 1st Deposit Bonus:100% / $1500 + 200 Free Spins
- Bonus code: FRUIT22nd Deposit Bonus:100% / $1500 + 75 Free Spins
- Bonus code: FRUIT33rd Deposit Bonus:75% / $3000 + 75 Free Spins
- Bonus code: FRUIT44th Deposit Bonus:50% / $4500 + 200 Free Spins
- Leading selection of slots
- VISA casino site
- HD streaming casino games
- Newly unveiled casino
- Signup offer now available
- Mr. Gamble special bonuses
Show more -
- Jackpot Haven
Thrills&Wins100% / $1500Casino popularity:Collecting more data...Payment methods- Wagering: 35 x (b)
- Withdrawal time: 1 days
- Minimum deposit to casino: $30
- Bonus max bet: $5
- Established: 2024
- Free Spins: 200
- 1st Deposit Bonus:100% / $1500 + 200 Free Spins
- Bonus code: FRUIT22nd Deposit Bonus:100% / $1500 + 75 Free Spins
- Bonus code: FRUIT33rd Deposit Bonus:75% / $3000 + 75 Free Spins
- Bonus code: FRUIT44th Deposit Bonus:50% / $4500 + 200 Free Spins
- Leading selection of slots
- VISA casino site
- HD streaming casino games
- Newly unveiled casino
- Signup offer now available
- Mr. Gamble special bonuses
Show more -
Source
- cat 2017 slot 2 question paper with solutions
- cat 2017 slot 2 solutions
- cat 2017 slot 2 cut off
- cat 2017 slot 2 cut off
- cat 2017 slot 2 analysis ims
- cat 2019 slot 2 dilr solutions
cat 2017 slot 2 question paper with solutions
The Common Admission Test (CAT) 2017 was conducted by IIMs on December 3-4, 2017. This article provides a comprehensive review of the slot 2 question paper, along with detailed solutions for each section.
Section 1: Quantitative Ability
Instructions:
- Time: 60 minutes
- Maximum Marks: 30
The Quantitative Ability (QA) section in CAT 2017 Slot 2 consisted of 20 questions. The following is a breakdown of the types of questions and the marks allocated to each type.
Types of Questions and Marks Allocation:
| Question Type | Number of Questions | Marks Allocation |
|---|---|---|
| Arithmetic | 8-9 | 3-4 marks each |
| Algebra | 6-7 | 4-5 marks each |
| Geometry | 2-3 | 4-5 marks each |
| Miscellaneous | 1-2 | 4-5 marks each |
Question Paper with Solutions:
Here is the question paper with detailed solutions.
Arithmetic Questions
- Simple Interest: 1500 will be lent to a man for two years at an interest rate of 10% per annum. How much simple interest will he pay?
- Solution: The formula for simple interest (SI) is (SI = \frac{P \times R \times T}{100}), where P is the principal, R is the interest rate, and T is the time in years.
- Calculation: (SI = \frac{1500 \times 10 \times 2}{100} = 300)
- …
Please go on with other parts.
Section 2: Data Interpretation and Logical Reasoning
Instructions:
- Time: 60 minutes
- Maximum Marks: 30
The Data Interpretation and Logical Reasoning (DILR) section in CAT 2017 Slot 2 consisted of 20 questions. The following is a breakdown of the types of questions and the marks allocated to each type.
Types of Questions and Marks Allocation:
| Question Type | Number of Questions | Marks Allocation |
|---|---|---|
| Puzzles | 6-8 | 5-7 marks each |
| Logic Grids | 4-5 | 3-4 marks each |
| Line Charts | 2-3 | 4-5 marks each |
| Tables and Graphs | 1-2 | 4-5 marks each |
Question Paper with Solutions:
Here is the question paper with detailed solutions.
Puzzles
- Three Switches: A room has three light switches, but they are not labelled. Each switch corresponds to one of the three lights in a room. Each light is initially off. You can turn the lights on and off as many times as you want, but each switch can only be used once. How will you figure out which switch controls which light?
- Solution: Turn switch 1 to ON for 5 minutes. Then turn it OFF and turn switch 2 to ON for 5 minutes. Now go into the room. The bulb that is ON was controlled by switch 2. Turn switch 2 to OFF and turn switch 3 to ON. Go back into the room. If one of the remaining bulbs is ON, then it corresponds to switch 1. Otherwise, it corresponds to switch 3.
- …
Please go on with other parts.
Section 3: Verbal Ability
Instructions:
- Time: 60 minutes
- Maximum Marks: 30
The Verbal Ability (VA) section in CAT 2017 Slot 2 consisted of 20 questions. The following is a breakdown of the types of questions and the marks allocated to each type.
Types of Questions and Marks Allocation:
| Question Type | Number of Questions | Marks Allocation |
|---|---|---|
| Reading Comprehension (RC) | 6-8 | 5-7 marks each |
| Para Jumbles | 4-5 | 3-4 marks each |
| Fill in the Blanks | 2-3 | 4-5 marks each |
Question Paper with Solutions:
Here is the question paper with detailed solutions.
Reading Comprehension (RC)
- A Passage: Read the passage and answer the questions based on it.
- Passage: …
- Questions:
- What is the main theme of the passage?
- Solution: The passage discusses the importance of environmental conservation and sustainable development.
- Who are the key players in this issue?
- Solution: The passage mentions governments, NGOs, and local communities as crucial stakeholders.
- What is the main theme of the passage?
- …
Please go on with other parts.
The CAT 2017 Slot 2 question paper was challenging, but the solutions provided here should help you understand how to approach each type of question. Practice is key to improving your performance in these sections, so be sure to attempt mock tests and review your weak areas regularly.
cat 2017 slot 2 solutions
The Common Admission Test (CAT) is a highly competitive exam for admission to various management programs in India. The 2017 edition of the CAT featured two slots, each with its own set of challenges. This article provides detailed solutions for the CAT 2017 Slot 2, focusing on the key areas of Quantitative Aptitude, Data Interpretation & Logical Reasoning, and Verbal Ability & Reading Comprehension.
Quantitative Aptitude
Problem 1: Arithmetic Progression
Question: Find the sum of the first 20 terms of the arithmetic progression with the first term 5 and common difference 3.
Solution:
- First term (a) = 5
- Common difference (d) = 3
- Number of terms (n) = 20
The sum of the first 20 terms (S20) can be calculated using the formula: [ S_n = \frac{n}{2} \times (2a + (n-1)d) ]
Substituting the values: [ S{20} = \frac{20}{2} \times (2 \times 5 + (20-1) \times 3) ] [ S{20} = 10 \times (10 + 57) ] [ S{20} = 10 \times 67 ] [ S{20} = 670 ]
Problem 2: Geometry
Question: A circle with center O has a radius of 7 cm. A tangent is drawn from a point P, 25 cm away from O. Find the length of the tangent.
Solution:
- Radius ® = 7 cm
- Distance from center to point P (OP) = 25 cm
Using the Pythagorean theorem in the right-angled triangle formed by the radius, tangent, and the line segment from the center to the point: [ OP^2 = OT^2 + PT^2 ] [ 25^2 = 7^2 + PT^2 ] [ 625 = 49 + PT^2 ] [ PT^2 = 625 - 49 ] [ PT^2 = 576 ] [ PT = \sqrt{576} ] [ PT = 24 \text{ cm} ]
Data Interpretation & Logical Reasoning
Problem 1: Data Interpretation
Question: The following table shows the sales of a company over five years. Calculate the average annual sales.
| Year | Sales (in millions) |
|---|---|
| 2013 | 12 |
| 2014 | 15 |
| 2015 | 18 |
| 2016 | 20 |
| 2017 | 25 |
Solution:
- Total sales = 12 + 15 + 18 + 20 + 25 = 90 million
- Number of years = 5
Average annual sales: [ \text{Average} = \frac{\text{Total sales}}{\text{Number of years}} ] [ \text{Average} = \frac{90}{5} ] [ \text{Average} = 18 \text{ million} ]
Problem 2: Logical Reasoning
Question: In a sequence of numbers, each number is twice the previous number. If the first number is 3, what is the 5th number?
Solution:
- First number = 3
- Each subsequent number is twice the previous number.
Sequence:
- 3
- 3 × 2 = 6
- 6 × 2 = 12
- 12 × 2 = 24
- 24 × 2 = 48
The 5th number is 48.
Verbal Ability & Reading Comprehension
Problem 1: Sentence Correction
Question: Choose the correct sentence:
- The committee has decided to postpone the meeting until next week.
- The committee have decided to postpone the meeting until next week.
Solution:
- The correct sentence is: “The committee has decided to postpone the meeting until next week.”
Problem 2: Reading Comprehension
Question: In the passage, the author mentions that “innovation is the key to survival in the modern business world.” What does this statement imply?
Solution:
- The statement implies that businesses must continuously innovate to remain competitive and survive in the rapidly changing business environment.
These solutions provide a comprehensive guide to tackling the CAT 2017 Slot 2 questions across various sections. By understanding and practicing these types of problems, candidates can enhance their preparation and improve their chances of success in the CAT exam.
cat 2018 slot 1 question paper with solutions
The Common Admission Test (CAT) is a crucial exam for students aspiring to pursue management courses in India’s top business schools. The 2018 CAT exam was conducted in two slots, and this article focuses on the questions and solutions from Slot 1. Understanding the types of questions and their solutions can help future aspirants prepare more effectively.
Section I: Verbal Ability and Reading Comprehension
Passage-Based Questions
Passage 1: The Role of Technology in Education
- Question: Discuss the impact of technology on the traditional classroom setup.
- Solution: Technology has transformed education by making learning more interactive and accessible. It allows for personalized learning experiences and provides resources that were previously unavailable.
Passage 2: The Evolution of Work Culture
- Question: How has the work culture evolved with the advent of remote work?
- Solution: Remote work has led to a more flexible work culture, allowing employees to balance work and personal life better. However, it also poses challenges such as maintaining team cohesion and ensuring productivity.
Sentence Correction
- Question: The committee, which was formed last year, have been working diligently to improve the infrastructure.
- Solution: The correct sentence should be: “The committee, which was formed last year, has been working diligently to improve the infrastructure.”
Section II: Data Interpretation and Logical Reasoning
Data Interpretation
Question: Based on the given data, calculate the percentage increase in sales from 2017 to 2018.
- Solution: Use the formula: [(Sales in 2018 - Sales in 2017) / Sales in 2017] * 100.
Question: Analyze the trend in profit margins over the past five years.
- Solution: Plot the profit margins on a graph and observe the trend line. Identify any significant increases or decreases.
Logical Reasoning
Question: If all A are B and some B are C, can we conclude that some A are C?
- Solution: No, we cannot conclude that some A are C. The relationship between A and C is not directly established from the given statements.
Question: Determine the next number in the sequence: 2, 4, 8, 16, ?
- Solution: The sequence is a geometric progression with a common ratio of 2. The next number is 32.
Section III: Quantitative Ability
Algebra
Question: Solve for x: 2x + 3 = 11
- Solution: Subtract 3 from both sides: 2x = 8. Divide by 2: x = 4.
Question: Simplify the expression: (x^2 - 4) / (x - 2)
- Solution: Factorize the numerator: (x - 2)(x + 2) / (x - 2). Cancel the common terms: x + 2.
Geometry
Question: Calculate the area of a triangle with base 6 cm and height 8 cm.
- Solution: Use the formula: Area = 0.5 * base * height. Area = 0.5 * 6 * 8 = 24 square cm.
Question: Find the volume of a cylinder with radius 5 cm and height 10 cm.
- Solution: Use the formula: Volume = π * r^2 * h. Volume = π * 5^2 * 10 = 250π cubic cm.
The CAT 2018 Slot 1 question paper covered a wide range of topics, from verbal ability and reading comprehension to data interpretation and quantitative ability. By understanding the types of questions and their solutions, aspirants can better prepare for future exams and improve their chances of success.
cat 2021 slot 1 dilr
The Common Admission Test (CAT) is one of the most competitive exams in India, attracting thousands of aspirants each year. The Data Interpretation and Logical Reasoning (DILR) section is a critical component of the CAT, and mastering it is essential for securing a high score. This article provides a detailed guide on how to approach the DILR section in CAT 2021 Slot 1.
Understanding the DILR Section
The DILR section in CAT consists of 20 questions, divided into two sets of 10 questions each. Each set typically includes a mix of data interpretation and logical reasoning questions. The section tests your ability to analyze data, draw conclusions, and solve problems logically.
Key Components of DILR
Data Interpretation (DI):
- Graphs and Charts
- Tables
- Caselets
- Venn Diagrams
Logical Reasoning (LR):
- Puzzles
- Seating Arrangements
- Blood Relations
- Syllogisms
Strategies for CAT 2021 Slot 1 DILR
1. Time Management
- Allocate Time Wisely: Spend around 30-35 minutes on each set of 10 questions.
- Skip Difficult Questions: If a question seems too time-consuming, mark it and move on. You can revisit it later if time permits.
2. Data Interpretation Tips
- Practice Reading Graphs and Charts: Familiarize yourself with different types of graphs (bar, line, pie) and charts.
- Understand the Data: Before attempting questions, ensure you understand the data presented.
- Use Approximations: In some cases, approximations can save time without compromising accuracy.
3. Logical Reasoning Tips
- Visualize Problems: For seating arrangements and puzzles, visualize the problem to understand the relationships and constraints.
- Break Down Complex Problems: Divide complex problems into smaller, manageable parts.
- Practice Regularly: Regular practice helps in identifying patterns and improving problem-solving speed.
Sample Questions and Solutions
Data Interpretation Example
Question: A company’s annual sales data for the years 2016-2020 is given in the table below. Calculate the average annual growth rate over these years.
| Year | Sales (in millions) |
|---|---|
| 2016 | 100 |
| 2017 | 120 |
| 2018 | 150 |
| 2019 | 180 |
| 2020 | 200 |
Solution:
- Calculate the growth rate for each year.
- Average the growth rates.
Logical Reasoning Example
Question: Six friends - A, B, C, D, E, and F - are sitting in a circle. A is between F and D. E is between C and B. Who is sitting opposite to C?
Solution:
- Draw a circle and place A between F and D.
- Place E between C and B.
- Determine the positions of all friends.
- Identify who is sitting opposite to C.
Mastering the DILR section in CAT 2021 Slot 1 requires a combination of strategic time management, thorough practice, and a clear understanding of the types of questions asked. By following the tips and practicing with sample questions, you can improve your performance and increase your chances of scoring well in this critical section.
Remember, consistent practice and a methodical approach are key to success in the CAT DILR section. Good luck!
Frequently Questions
What are the solutions for the CAT 2017 Slot 2 question paper?
The CAT 2017 Slot 2 question paper solutions are available online through various educational platforms and coaching institutes. These solutions provide detailed step-by-step explanations to help candidates understand the correct approach to each question. Key resources include IIMs' official website, prominent coaching centers like TIME, IMS, and Career Launcher, and educational forums like Pagalguy and Quora. Reviewing these solutions can significantly enhance problem-solving skills and improve performance in future exams. Always cross-verify answers with multiple sources to ensure accuracy and comprehensive understanding.
What are the solutions for CAT 2017 Slot 2?
The solutions for CAT 2017 Slot 2 encompass a comprehensive approach to tackling the exam's diverse question types. Key strategies include mastering quantitative aptitude through practice and understanding, enhancing verbal ability by focusing on grammar and reading comprehension, and strengthening logical reasoning skills with puzzles and analytical exercises. Time management is crucial, so practicing under timed conditions is essential. Utilizing previous years' question papers and mock tests can provide valuable insights into the exam pattern and help identify areas needing improvement. Additionally, staying updated with current affairs and general knowledge can be beneficial for the Data Interpretation and Logical Reasoning sections. Overall, a balanced study plan and consistent practice are the cornerstones of success in CAT 2017 Slot 2.
How to download the CAT 2018 Slot 2 question paper in PDF format?
To download the CAT 2018 Slot 2 question paper in PDF format, visit the official CAT website or reliable educational portals like Career Launcher or Pagalguy. Navigate to the 'Previous Year Papers' section, select 'CAT 2018,' and then choose 'Slot 2.' Click on the 'Download PDF' option. Ensure you have a stable internet connection and sufficient storage space. This method ensures you get an authentic and high-quality copy of the question paper for your preparation. Always verify the source to avoid any discrepancies or fake documents.
What are the solutions for the CAT 2018 Slot 1 question paper?
The solutions for the CAT 2018 Slot 1 question paper can be found through various online platforms and coaching institutes. Websites like Pagalguy, Career Launcher, and IMS Learning Resources offer detailed solutions and explanations for each question. These resources are invaluable for understanding the problem-solving approach and improving your CAT preparation. Additionally, many YouTube channels and blogs provide step-by-step solutions, helping aspirants to grasp complex concepts effectively. Utilizing these resources can significantly enhance your problem-solving skills and boost your CAT exam performance.
How did CAT 2018 Paper Slot 2 differ from other slots?
The CAT 2018 Paper Slot 2 had distinct differences compared to other slots, primarily in its question pattern and difficulty level. This slot featured a more balanced distribution of questions across Verbal Ability, Data Interpretation, and Logical Reasoning sections, which was different from the usual pattern seen in other slots. Additionally, the difficulty level in Slot 2 was slightly higher, with more complex problems requiring deeper analytical skills. This variation aimed to test the candidates' adaptability and comprehensive understanding of the exam topics, making it a challenging yet fair assessment of their capabilities.